Gustavo Gutiérrez, famed progenitor of Latin American Liberation Theology, died in his native Peru nearly two years ago. For those who know his name as that of a pioneering liberation theologian, a closer examination of his work reveals that he did not “invent” liberation theology any more than Aquinas and Bonaventure invented High Scholasticism. Just as the latter took up the pressing social concerns and intellectual developments of their day—from the mendicant movement to cutting-edge translations of Arabic philosophy—and constructed new architectonic frames to address them, so too did Gutiérrez take up emerging historical developments and address the latest philosophical and theological research. He wrote in medias res, fervently and ceaselessly, and he taught and engaged with contemporary issues and debates in multiple fields of philosophy, politics, and theology.
The radical arguments he made in the 1970s did not soften as he traveled from Peru to the United States or from his parish in Lima to the North American Midwest. His legacy requires safeguarding from those Christians would read his theology in the most minimal and reformist sense, turning the preferential option for the poor into a call for personal compassion and modest social reforms–though some may be eager to engage him in this way. His debts to decolonial Marxism, as well as his unyielding commitment to socialism as the specific structural goal of economic and political liberation, cannot and should not be excised from his thought.
At the same time, the fact that his contribution took the form of liberation theology remains central. Gutiérrez did not, as some have accused him, cook up a hodgepodge of secular political concepts with a dash of spiritual flair. His project is theological at its heart, at the margins, and at every point in between. His socialist commitments and theological anthropology were informed by an understanding of the profound unity of nature and grace.
This unity of the human vocation made him a dogged critic of any model proposing a clean separation between the spiritual and the political or the eternal and the temporal. His God is a God in history. His church is a Church from and for the world. And his politics was socialist.
~ ~ ~
When his seminal work Teología de la liberació was first published in 1971 by the Peruvian Centro de Estudios y Publicaciones, Latin America was deep in the throes of social turmoil. The explosive 1968 episcopal conference at Medellín, Colombia—so crucial for the emergence of liberation thinking—had already taken place. And for decades, the continent had been rocked by violent political struggle, including the Bolivian Revolution in 1952, the American-backed coup in Guatemala in 1954, the Cuban Revolution between 1952-1959, and the four-day Football War in 1969 between El Salvador and Honduras. In Peru, Gutiérrrez’s home country, the fifties and sixties were no less tumultuous. Peru suffered through a series of coups and military dictatorships as well as an oil-related economic crisis.
Gutiérrez’s Latin American context is crucial to understanding the stakes of his theology of liberation. Take, for example, the 1960s emancipatory movements in North America and Western Europe. Although Gutierrez makes use of these international movements, he insisted that a conception of freedom must take place within Latin America, not outside of it. The political and economic evils faced by the Latin American people require specific contextual formulations. While acknowledging the legitimacy of student movements that seek liberation from “subtle forms of oppression in the heart of advanced industrial societies” (Theology of Liberation), he was adamant that their task should not be confused with what peoples outside the imperial core need:
The context in the rich countries, however, is quite different from that of the poor countries,” he writes, “we must beware of all kinds of imitations as well as new forms of imperialism–revolutionary this time–of the rich countries, which consider themselves central to the history of humankind. Such mimicry would only lead the revolutionary groups of the Third World to a new deception regarding their own reality. They would be led to fight against windmills.
Still, the history of modern revolutionary politics and the attendant emergence of mass democracy and emancipatory politics struck Gutiérrez as both irreversible and positive. “It was above all the great social revolutions–the French and the Russian, for example, to mention only two important milestones–together with the whole process of revolutionary ferment that they initiated which wrested–or at least began to–political decisions from the hands of an elite who were ‘destined’ to rule.”
Yet, for the articulation of an authentic and self-sustaining liberation theology, threats remained. He feared a homogenous understanding of revolutionary Enlightenment would place Latin America in a Procrustean bed of analysis. He also worried that a one-sided definition of “secularization” would ignore or totally annihilate the theological substance of the liberation approach.
The first concern was already seriously considered among Latin American intellectuals in the context of revolutionary politics. The episcopal conference of 1968 in Medellin expressed this demand: Latin America requires a new meaning of what it means to be Church from a vantage point external to Europe. The argument is analogous to Latin American revolutionaries defending their unique struggle over and against some European imposition. Gutiérrez presented this analogy clearly in his treatment of José Carlos Mariátegui. Gutiérrez quoted Mariátegui:
We do not wish for socialism in America to be an exact copy of others’ socialism, It must be a heroic creation. We must bring Indo-American socialism to life with our own reality, in our own language. This is a mission worthy of a new generation.
In Gutiérrez’s citations of Mariategui, we see parallels to Aquinas and other Scholastics citing Aristotle in their works—highly controversial at the time,even leading to the episcopal condemnations of the Angelic Doctor. Aquinas stood as Gutierrez’s model. He participated in the long Catholic traditions of receiving new resources from many modes of learning and attempted to update theology in light of what experience, science, and reflection bring us. And when Gutiérrez proposed, beyond the modes of wisdom and rational knowledge, a new additional locus of theology to take up questions of historical liberation, political praxis, and prophetic critique, he looked for insights into method just as Aquinas borrowed his understanding of what constitutes scientia from Aristotelian episteme.
~ ~ ~
The struggle for an indigenous socialism has further correspondences in Gutiérrez’s thought. It brings to light how the question of justice and liberation required concrete mobilization and an awareness of the “different kinds of violence… present between groups with different interests and opinions.” True peace does not mean papering over class conflict, structural injustice, and exploitation, pretending that through a merely abstract spiritual unity, Christianity has overcome the world, the flesh, and the devil. It means pressing against the barriers that obstruct the development of true peace, peace rooted in the truth of justice.
The question of indigenous socialism also reveals Gutiérrez’ spirituality and insistence that Peruvians, Latin Americans, and all peoples must drink from their own wells. This is not an attack on the universality of the Christian mystery–our encounter with God, with Christ the Lord, must be embedded in our time and place. Faith as a genuine search for answers must transform the way the Gospel is preached. The historical, ecclesial, and political horizons of human life are woven together, threads impossible to disentangle.
Because of these entangled horizons, Gutiérrez was concerned for a form of historical liberation, hoping that theologians would maintain the position of “organic intellectuals”and remain within a recognizable context of Latin American communities.
He was also fiercely protective of the distinctively spiritual context of his understanding of liberation, rooted in ecclesial faith and a rigorous theological architecture. Insofar as “secularization” referred to a breakdown of the “two ends” theory of Church and State, Gutiérrez approved. But he rejected an understanding of secularism where the temporal and physical realm are rigidly and hierarchically subordinated to the spiritual and eternal one. Positively, secularization meant the discovery of the human as a creative subject in a more explicit mode. It is the widespread realization that all men and women desire to be crowned and mitred lords of themselves, and that this is a goal that must be attempted on earth and not reserved for heaven alone. Secularization represents a deepening of the implications of the Incarnation in the political and social realm.
Yet Gutiérrez also refuses an understanding of secularization as an autonomy free of transcendence. Such an understanding would require a strict separation between an allegedly “spiritual” search for God and an ostensibly “worldly” quest for justice and liberation. This separation is impossible on exegetical, theological, and historical grounds. Building upon Henri de Lubac, Gutiérrez holds that the antithesis of the sacred against the secular relies on the same logic as the antithesis of nature against supernature.
In A Theology of Liberation, Gutiérrez narrates the history of the theological concept of natura pura as it emerged in late Scholasticism (with a dubious relationship to the thought of Aquinas himself). The concept of a human nature, enclosed and complete in itself, held that no nature can lack what it needs for the attainment of its perfection. Yet, if God is the true end and perfection of human desire, then how could God deny that end to any? Therefore, the gratuitous character of salvation could only be secured by separating the beatific vision and the divine life from the normal integrity of human nature, not only God but any desire for God could only be elicited as a donum superadditum. At least, this was the logic of Cajetan and many later Thomists all the way up through the early twentieth century. Gutiérrez sees natura pura as already obsolete at the time of his writing in 1971. Urging his readers to study Henri de Lubac’s Mystery of the Supernatural, he remarked that “[t]he doctrine of pure nature has been completely abandoned in contemporary theology.” He bolstered his theological roster on this issue with the giants of Catholic Ressourcement theology: Joseph Marechal, Maurice Blondel, Karl Rahner, and Yves de Montecheuil. The inclusion of de Lubac and de Montecheuil also elevates the political implications of such a theological anthropology as both these French Jesuits were active Resistance members in Nazi-occupied France against the Vichy collaborators (the polar theological and political opposites of Neo-Thomist supporters of Franco and Petain like Reginald Gerrigou-Lagrange, who defended the idea of the vision of God as a pure donum superadditum: gratuitous gift).
Gutiérrez saw the demolition of the Baroque scholastic nature/supernature dualism as having profound spiritual and political implications: “In the concrete situation there is but one vocation: communion with God through grace,” he writes. “In reality there is no pure nature and there never has been; there is no one who is not invited to communion with the Lord, no one who is not affected by grace.” The human condition, and the condition of the whole cosmos, is “transnatural.”
~ ~ ~
What are the implications? Theologically, there are many. The Church cannot be the logical opposite of the World. In the words of Johann Baptiste Metz, “the Church is not the Non-World.” The legitimate autonomy of the World, on the other hand, does not make it the Non-Church. In light of this, the dual paradigm for Church and State “appears as a burnt-out model with nothing to say to advances in theological thinking.” Creation and salvation are, ultimately, a single act. Gutiérrez insisted that “profane history” and “sacred history” are really “one history—a ‘Christo-finalized’ history.” In the biblical narratives, the role of creative human labor is paramount. Adam and Eve are made sacred artists and priestly guardians of the earth: this insight prompts the rabbis of Genesis Rabbah to continually debate when the earth was finished being created or if we are still joined with God in continuing the original creative act.
The profound theology of creative labor Gutiérrez saw in the biblical narratives provides even more strength to his argument that temporal progress cannot be siloed off as a category indifferent to the Kingdom of God. The order of creation and the order of redemption are imbricated and inseparable. Any understanding of progress that fails to outline the vast material and structural exploitation conducted by the capitalist class or neglects to attend to the imperialist extraction of resources by Global North from the Global South also fails to be a true account of divine liberation. Gutiérrez saw no path to the Kingdom that evades the concrete conditions of politics and economics, and he did not hesitate to call those political and economic conditions by their proper theological name: sin. This ancient theological category includes individual actions as well as social forms. He writes:
Sin is evident in oppressive structures, in the exploitation of humans by humans, in the domination and slavery of peoples, races, and social classes. Sin appears, therefore, as the fundamental alienation, the root of a situation of injustice and exploitation…Sin demands a radical liberation, which in turn necessarily implies a political liberation.
As to what Gutiérrez had in mind as the specific form of political and economic liberation, he left no doubt. He pointed out that the socialists have most often taken up the task of Latin American liberation, but he did not seek for Christian liberation to “purify” socialism into some nebulously Catholic social insights.
Gutiérrez endorsed socialism substantively and comprehensively as exhibiting “the most fruitful and far-reaching approach.” Over and over again, he brought forward the witness of priests and bishops in Mexico, Bolivia, Argentina, Chile, and Colombia who explicitly advocated for socialism as a vital part of the struggle for liberation. The entire structure of A Theology of Liberation, insofar as it concerns the concrete conditions in Latin America, was an extended argument opposing reformism and any approach to so-called economic “development” that remained capitalist in structure. And once reform of capitalist and neocolonial structures had been rejected as futile, as Gutiérrez believed, only leftward horizons remain open for liberation. It is for this reason that Gutiérrez brought examples and statements from revolutionary socialists and communists like José Carlos Mariátegui, Che Guevara, Camillo Torres Restrepo, and Néstor Paz Zamora into his writings and arguments.
Humanity has one vocation: union with God and the building of the Kingdom. However utopian it might seem, Gutiérrez was persuaded that the most practical and physical questions of poverty as well as the most metaphysical and spiritual questions of divinity meet in history. It is fitting that Gutiérrez cited Néstor Paz Zamora, the revolutionary Bolivian Catholic, who combined devotion to St. Francis with communist militancy:
I believe that the fight for liberation is rooted in the prophetic line of Salvation-History…we believe in a new man, made free by the blood and resurrection of Jesus. We believe in a New Earth where love will be the fundamental law.
Andrew Kuiper writes about literature, philosophy, theology, mysticism, and politics for a variety of publications and on Substack under the name Naucratic Expeditions.
Image Credit: Mohan, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons. A rose (Rosa species): flowering stem. Watercolour. Wellcome Collection. Source: Wellcome Collection. Public Domain.